All players are seniors unless otherwise noted.

First offense

E--Matt St. Clair, Peru-7, jr.
E--Mike Oertel, Peru-7, jr.
L--Craig Swanson, Bethpage-8
L--Liam Murray, Oneonta-4
L--Robert Roosa, Rondout Valley-9
L--Ed Greene, Broadalbin-Perth-2
L--Tom Kazmierczak, Depew-6
QB--Matt Bezio, Peru-7, jr. (player of the year)
RB--Josh Johnston, Harborfields-11
RB--Brian Leonard, Gouverneur-10
RB--Rob Smith, Somers-1

First defense
E--Chris Brunell, Peru-7
L--Kelsey Jenks, Chenango Forks-4, jr.
L--Andrew Weininger, Harrison-1, jr.
L--Brian Nary, Olean-6
LB--Chris Boyd, Red Hook-9
LB--Jim Nelson, Southwestern-6 
LB--Darwin Powell, Harborfields-11 
LB--Keith Smith, Bath-5
HB--Rashad Barksdale, Hudson-2
HB--John Russ, Honeoye Falls-Lima-5
S--Jamison Koesterer, Cazenovia-3, jr.

Second offense
E--Craig Perkins, Cazenovia-3, jr.
E-K--Mike Wall, Solvay-3, jr.
L--Mark Calzone, Southwestern-6 
L--Ken Hall, Glens Falls-2, jr.
L--Casey Flynn, Somers-1 
L--Scott Anderson, Oneida-3 
L--Juan Mendoza, Chenango-Forks-4, jr.
QB--Andy Lytwynec, Ilion-3 
RB--Sean Guyette, Alden-6 
RB--James Faello, Manhasset-8 
RB--Jamie Hoover, Chenango Forks-4

Second defense
E--Joe Bulone, Seaford-8
L--Mark Fiore, Harrison-1
L--Josh Mrugula, Springville-6
L--Jake Frisch, Chenango Forks-4, jr.
E--Adam Kulczycky, Cazenovia-3 
LB--Matt Dardani, Ravena-2 
LB--Brad Watkins, Albion-6 
LB--Rudy Arcara, Harrison-1, jr.
HB--Geoff Bean, Oneonta-4, jr.
HB--Jason Lockwood, Hornell-5 
S--Roy Deyo, Chenango Forks-4

Third offense
E--Kyle McCann, Ilion-3 
L--Chris Locke, B.G.-Afton-4, jr.
L--Mike Beatty, Johnstown-2 
L--Evan Kivlen, Saranac Lake-7
L--Ryan Keene, Waverly-4 
L--Mike Liscum, Gouverneur-10
QB--Pat Manuel, Elmira Notre Dame-4 
HB--Anton Armstead, New Paltz-9 
RB--Chris Jones, Roosevelt-8 
RB--Charlie Campany, Vernon-Verona-Sherrill-3 
RB--Jon Winston, Nanuet-1, jr.

Third defense
L--Raymond Blagman, Roosevelt-8
L--Nick McGill, Roundout Velley-9, jr.
L--Nate Kaster, Hudson-2 
LB--Shawn Horton, Broadalbin-Perth-2 
LB--Jack Garland, Somers-1 
LB--Mike Abdo, Olean-6 
LB--Derrick Warburton, Cheektowaga-6 
LB--Chris Sebald, Rondout Valley-9, jr.
HB--Paul Izzo, Cohoes-2, jr. 
HB--Jordan Rabidou, Somers-1, jr. 
S--Sal Geraci, Harrison-1