2019 (Section 3 vs. Section 1 opponents)
    Class AA, Utica Proctor
      Lost to New Rochelle, 21-7
    Class A, Auburn
      Lost to Rye, 49-13
    Class D, Waterville
      Lost to Tuckahoe, 12-6

2020 (no tournament due to pandemic)

2021 (Section 1 vs. Sections 7 and 9)
    Class AA, Arlington
      Lost to Newburgh Free Academy, 35-34 (OT)
    Class A, Rye
      Def. Minisink Valley, 31-21
      Lost to Somers, 14-7
    Class D, Haldane
      Lost to Moriah, 22-0

2022 (Section 5 vs. Section 2)
    Class AA, Pittsford
      Lost to Albany CBA, 27-6
    Class A, Canandaigua*
      Lost to Niskayuna, 14-7

    Class D, Alexander
      Lost to Cambridge/Salem, 12-7

2023 (Section 2 vs. Section 1)
    Class AA, Shenendehowa
      Lost to Carmel, 28-14
    Class A, Averill Park
      Lost to Somers, 31-7

2024 (Section 4 vs. Section 9)
    Class AA, Corning
      Def. Monroe-Woodbury, 26-13
      Lost to Albany CBA, 56-7
    Class A, Vestal
      Lost to Cornwall, 25-12

2025 (Section 9 vs. Section 2)

2026 (Section 6 vs. Section 1)

* -- In 2022, Section 5 split its Class A field into two tournaments, with both winners advancing to the NYSPHSAA quarterfinals, one as the Section 5 representative and one as the wildcard.