All players are seniors unless otherwise noted.

First offense
E--Mike Affronti, Commack-11
E--Harrison Tindall, Susan Wagner-NYC
L--Matt Speiss, Patchogue-Medford-11
L--Brad Sullivan, Orchard Park-6
L--D'Brickashaw Ferguson, Freeport-8
L--Chris Auletta, St. Anthony-CHSFL
QB--Greg Rommel, Syracuse Henninger-3
RB--Carl Garritano, Webster-5, jr. (player of the year)
RB--Phil DeCosta, North Rockland-1
RB--Damien Rhodes, Fayetteville-Manlius-3
RB--Glenroy Watkins, Sheepshead Bay-NYC
 
First defense
L--Rick Eicheldinger, Lancaster-6
L--Ernest Jones, Lehman-NYC
L--Sean Thomas, Newburgh Free-9
LB--Kelvin Smith, North Rockland-1
LB--Elliot Goode, Fayetteville-Manlius-3
LB--Jerry Mackey Jr., Freeport-8
LB--Matt Albanese, Farmingdale-8, jr.
HB--Chris Williams, Orchard Park-6
HB--RaQuan Pride, Syracuse Corcoran-3
HB-K-Adam Podlesh, Pittsford-5
K--Keith Brown, Vestal-4

Second offense
E--Chris Turner, Syracuse Henninger-3
E--David Ferris, St. Francis-6-CHS
L--Kevin Trogoris, Shenendehowa-2
L--Todd Mulligan, Troy-2
L--Ryan Poles, Canandaigua-5, jr.
L--Justin Laurienzo, Lancaster-6
QB--Mike Radon, St. Francis-6-CHS
RB--Pat Heenan, Bethlehem-2
RB--Jo-Lonn Dunbar, Syracuse Corcoran-3, jr.
RB--Jason Colson, Rochester Edison-5
RB--Chad Rissland, William Floyd-11
 
Second defense
E--Markese Brown, Syracuse Henninger-3
E--Jerrett Foster, Clarkstown South-1 
L--Leslie Bartholomew, Lehman-NYC
L--Josh Hite, Fayetteville-Manlius-3
L--Jacob Hobbs, Schenectady-2
LB--Chris Beh, Webster-5
LB--Joe Muratore, Sachem-11
LB--Eric Rupp, Lancaster-6
HB--Chris McDuffie, Williamsville North-6 5
HB--Travis Jinks, Freeport-8
S-K--Michael Torres, North Rockland-1

Third offense
E—Matt Green, Canandaigua-5
E--Andy Sturzenbecker, Jamestown-6, jr.
L--Matt Kuenzel, Saratoga-2
L--John Peralta, North Rockland-1
L--Joe Scalice, North Tonawanda-6
L-Michael Levato, Pittsford-5
E--Shea D'Ambrosia, Webster-5
QB--Jeff Krieger, Webster-5
RB--P.J. Deguire, Albany CBA-2
RB --Travis Cyrus, Churchville-Chili-5
RB--Jamie Anderson, Canandaigua-5

Third defense
E--Damian McCaig, Curtis-NYC
L--Dan Wilson, North Rockland-1, jr.
L--Bob Martinsen, Vestal-4
L--Ryan Ballinger, Gates Chili-5
LB--Michael Taylor, Rochester East-5
LB--Tom Genovisi, Columbia-2, jr.
LB--Rob Bonaguro, Farmingdale-8
HB--Kevin Micha, Binghamton-4
HB--Andy Mead, Baldwinsville-3
HB--Kyle Dowd, Northport-11
S--Gregg Damon, North Rockland-1

Fourth offense
E--Kyle Smith, St. Francis-6-CHS
E--Anthony Morat, Rome Free-3, jr.
L--John Fulfree, St. Anthony-CHSFL
L--Eben Blanchard, Webster-5
L--Jon Geddes, Colonie-2, jr.
L--Tim Aulet, Ramapo-1, jr.
L--Quenzell Smith, Syracuse Henninger-3
E--Ozzie Mathis, Syracuse Corcoran-3
QB--Mark Bulger, Bethlehem-2
RB--Matt Grant, Baldwinsville-3. jr.
RB--Desmond Maxwell, Lehman-NYC

Fourth defense
E--Chris Zambrano, St. Francis Prep-NYC
L--Joe Rozmus, West Seneca West-6
L--Brett Barrie, Baldwinsville-3, jr.
LB--Nick Feightner, Fayetteville-Manlius-3
LB--Mark DiFrancesca, Greece Olympia-5
LB--Gene Lang, Baldwinsville-3, jr.
LB--Ricky Ambeau, Gates Chili-5
HB--Bill Whelly, Bishop Maginn-2
HB--A.J. Covella, Spencerport-5
HB--Pat Meade, Schenectady-2
S--John O'Neil, Iona Prep-1