| | Player of the Year | | | |
| RB/LB | Tyson Totten, Pembroke-5 | Jr. | 5-11 | 155 |
| | First Team | | | |
| QB | Jackson Ludlow, Thousand Islands-3 | Jr. | | |
| QB | Martino Rocco, Frankfort-Schuyler-3 | So. | 5-8 | 168 |
| QB | Brayden Shepardson, West Canada Valley-3 | Sr. | 6-1 | 170 |
| QB | Austin Hunt, Groton-4 | Sr. | 5-11 | 180 |
| QB | Dan Collins, Spackenkill-9 | Jr. | 6-3 | 220 |
| QB | Austin Hartman, Tri-Valley-9 | Sr. | 5-7 | 155 |
| RB | Kyler Proper, Moravia-4 | Jr. | 5-8 | 155 |
| RB | Chandler Wright, Trumansburg-4 | Jr. | 6-0 | 181 |
| RB | Keegan Foote, Canisteo-Greenwood-5 | Sr. | 5-8 | 175 |
| RB | Freddie Heymach, Pawling-9 | Sr. | 5-9 | 170 |
| RB | Casmiro Pomales, Ellenville-9 | Sr. | 6-1 | 200 |
| RB | Sidney Stracher, Pine Plains/Rhinebeck-9 | Sr. | 5-6 | 175 |
| OE | Joe Baylor, Moravia-4 | So. | 6-3 | 180 |
| OE | Ben DeMatteo, Groton-4 | Sr. | 6-0 | 150 |
| OL | Gaige Goodsell, Groton-4 | Sr. | 6-2 | 215 |
| OL | Jayden Mast, Pembroke-5 | Jr. | 5-6 | 175 |
| AP | James Dapson III, Morrisville-Eaton-3 | Sr. | 5-10 | 150 |
| DL | Trent Sibble, Bolivar-Richburg-5 | Sr. | 6-2 | 225 |
| LB | Luke Paparella, New York Mills-3 | Sr. | 6-2 | 250 |
| DB | Cayden Pfalzer, Pembroke-5 | Sr. | 6-3 | 165 |
| LB | Dylan Poley, Tri-Valley-9 | Sr. | 5-10 | 187 |
| | | | | |
| | | | | |
| | Honorable Mention: | | | |
| QB | Bruno Kinsey (Bishop Grimes-3, Sr.), Luke Landis (Moravia-4, Jr.) | | | |
| RB | Riley Jones (Moravia-4, So.), Nick Karandeyev (Groton-4, Jr.) | | | |
| OE | Lionell Coulthurst (Frankfort-Schuyler-3, So.), Iain Farber (West Canada Valley-3, Jr.), Cale Marland (Morrisville-Eaton-3, Sr.), Carter Usher (Spackenkill-9, Sr.) | | | |
| Line | Noah Holt (Pawling-9, Sr.), Ian Mullen (Tri-Valley-9, Sr.), Allyn Stavanau (Spackenkill-9, Sr.) | | | |
| LB | Ryan Komick (New York Mills-3, Jr.) | | | |
| | | | | |
| | | | | |