First team-offense
E - Alex Neutz, sr., Grand Island-6
E - Robert Bellairs, sr., Plainedge-8
L - Ryan Wilson, sr., Sweet Home-6
L - Steve Phillips, sr., Sweet Home-6
L - Dave Frederickson, sr., Poly Prep-AIS
L - Terrence Fede, sr., Nyack-1
QB - Kevin Arduino, sr., Cornwall-9
RB - Seamus Kelly, sr. Xavier-CHS
RB - Curtis Dukes, sr., Indian River-10
RB - Austin Rose, sr., Corning West-4
RB - James Brundage, sr., Ossining-1

First-team defense
L - John Fennessy, sr., Yorktown-1
L - John Urschel, sr., Canisius-CHS-6
L - Darryl Parker, sr., Aquinas-5
L - Pat Wilson, sr., Canisius-CHS-6
LB - John Jansen, sr., Wantagh-8
LB - Devin Worthington, sr., Aquinas-5
LB - Rob Lombardo, sr., Somers-1
LB - Connor Hadcock, sr., Burnt Hills-2
HB - Bundaka Kargbo, sr., Bishop Maginn-2
KB - D.J. Forbragd, sr., Camden-3
K - Paul Layton, sr., Burnt Hills-2

Second-team offense
E - Sherman Nelson, sr., Carthage-3
E - Nick Stover, jr., Sayville-11
L - Ryan Schermehorn, sr., Fox Lane-1
L - Boomer Brock, sr., Iroquois-6
L - Conor Horl, jr., Garden City-8
L - Jonathan Reali, sr., Half Hollow Hills West-11
QB - Casey Kacz, jr., Sweet Home-6
RB - Casey Vogl, sr., Aquinas-5
RB - Justin Mayers, sr., Elmont-8
RB - Brandon Murie, sr., Iroquois-6
QB - Chris Rose, sr., Victor-5

Second-team defense
L - Steven Butler, sr., Port Jervis-9
L - James Torres, sr., Bishop Maginn-2
L - Anthony Davis, sr., Nyack-1
L - Home Dobransky, sr., Carthage-3
L - Chris Walters, sr., Maine-Endwell-4
LB - Kevin Clueckert, sr., Bethpage-8
LB - Damir Redzepagic, sr., Cardinal Spellman-CHS
LB - Deshanaro Morris, jr., Sweet Home-6
LB - Chuck Beckwith, sr., Victor-5
HB - Dominic Leonard, sr., Nyack-1
S - Dwayne Smith, sr., Aquinas-5

Third-team offense
E - Craig Zuzek, Cornwall-9
E - Jesse Drinks, sr., Ossining-1
L - Anthony Harper, sr., Syracuse Nottingham-3
L - Josh Hargrave, sr., Corning West-4
L - Mike Lewandowski, sr., Troy-2
QB - Mike Doyle, sr., New Hartford-3
RB - Devon Osei, sr., Cardinal Spellman-CHS
RB - Dustin Moss, jr., East Syracuse-Minia-3
RB - Kevin Chillis, sr., Buffalo McKinley-6
RB - Robert Joseph, sr., Poly Prep-AIS
RB - Joe Carcone, jr., New Hartford-3

Third-team defense
E - Nick Dobson, sr., Corning West-4
E - Jeremy Burnett, sr., Harrison-1
L - Mike Smith, sr., Grover Cleveland-6
LB - R.J. Roth, sr., Cornwall-9
LB - D.J. Ingham, jr., Fulton-3
LB - Trent Alls, sr., Buffalo Riverside-6
HB - Steve Hongac, sr., Xavier-CHS
HB - Ben Miseikis, sr., Amsterdam-2
HB - Justin Kreamer, sr., Ossining-1
HB - Randy Tillman, sr., Harborfields-11
K - Jack Nickla, sr., Bellport-11