| | Player of the year | | | |
| | Caden Bellis, Tioga-4 | Sr. | 5-11 | 170 |
| | First Team Offense | | | |
| QB | Derrick Zehr, Beaver River-3 | Sr. | 6-3 | 205 |
| QB | Tate Catanese, Clymer/Sherman/Panama-6 | Jr. | 6-0 | 200 |
| RB | Jaxon Mueller, Stillwater-2 | Sr. | 6-4 | 230 |
| RB | Trevor Borst, Dolgeville-3 | Jr. | | |
| RB | Drew Macumber, Tioga-4 | Sr. | 5-10 | 179 |
| RB | Jack Mahar, Wilson-6 | Sr. | 5-9 | 160 |
| OE | Valentino Rossi, Tioga-4 | Sr. | 6-4 | 192 |
| OE | Bryce Hinsdale, Clymer/Sherman/Panama-6 | Jr. | 5-10 | 155 |
| OL | Tyler Powers, Warrensburg/Lake George/Bolt-2 | Sr. | 6-0 | 260 |
| OL | Tate McCauley, Tioga-4 | Jr. | 6-2 | 245 |
| OL | Grant Lictus, Clymer/Sherman/Panama-6 | Sr. | 5-11 | 220 |
| AP | Evan Sickler, Tioga-4 | Sr. | 6-3 | 185 |
| PK | Gavin Fisher, Tioga-4 | Sr. | 6-3 | 178 |
| | First Team Defense | | | |
| DL | J.J. Reese, Canisteo-Greenwood-5 | Sr. | 6-3 | 190 |
| DL | Joseph Perone, Burke Catholic-9 | Sr. | 6-2 | 200 |
| LB | Evan Giachinta, Haldane-1 | Sr. | 6-2 | 200 |
| LB | James Cocozzo, Stillwater-2 | Fr. | 6-3 | 230 |
| LB | Mason Ennist, Sandy Creek-3 | Sr. | 6-2 | 198 |
| LB | Ousmane Duncanson, Tioga-4 | Sr. | 6-0 | 175 |
| LB | Beau Zeh, Canisteo-Greenwood-5 | Sr. | 5-8 | 170 |
| LB | Christopher Thompson, Avon-5 | Sr. | 5-10 | 155 |
| LB | Liam Benzinger, Burke Catholic-9 | Sr. | 5-10 | 188 |
| DB | Connor Benke, Tuckahoe-1 | Sr. | 6-2 | 180 |
| DB | Cody Hyney, Canajoharie/Fort Plain-2 | Jr. | 6-3 | 160 |
| | Second Team Offense | | | |
| QB | Ryan VanTassel, Haldane-1 | Sr. | 6-0 | 180 |
| QB | Caden Allen, Warrensburg/Lake George/Bolt-2 | Sr. | 5-9 | 165 |
| RB | Lucas Lilac, Stillwater-2 | Sr. | 6-2 | 165 |
| RB | Dom Jones, Mount Markham-3 | Sr. | 6-1 | 245 |
| RB | Zymere Smith, Clyde-Savannah-5 | So. | 5-11 | 190 |
| RB | Logan Gilbo, Moriah-7 | Sr. | 5-10 | 150 |
| OE | Jack Welch, Warrensburg/Lake George/Bolt-2 | Jr. | 6-2 | 185 |
| OE | Kade Schneider, Beaver River-3 | Jr. | 5-11 | 150 |
| OE | Alex Barmore, Clymer/Sherman/Panama-6 | Jr. | 6-2 | 175 |
| OL | Brett Mosher, Dolgeville-3 | Sr. | 6-1 | 165 |
| OL | Isaiah Ploetz, Franklinville/Ellicottville-6 | Sr. | 5-10 | 185 |
| AP | Hunter Smith, Franklinville/Ellicottville-6 | Sr. | 5-10 | 165 |
| PK | Landen Staie, Stillwater-2 | Jr. | | |
| | Second Team Defense | | | |
| DL | Colby Phraner, Walton-4 | Sr. | 6-2 | 236 |
| DL | Cooper Allen, Moriah-7 | Jr. | 6-4 | 210 |
| LB | Matt Conlin, Greenwich-2 | Sr. | 6-2 | 240 |
| LB | Nick Jeckel, Warrensburg/Lake George/Bolt-2 | Jr. | 6-2 | 205 |
| LB | Deacon Schneider, Cambridge/Salem-2 | Sr. | 5-10 | 180 |
| LB | Jaeden Darling, Sandy Creek-3 | Jr. | 5-10 | 184 |
| LB | Collin Ryan, Clymer/Sherman/Panama-6 | Jr. | 5-10 | 175 |
| LB | Boden Valentine, Moriah-7 | Sr. | 5-9 | 155 |
| DB | Jax Colaccio, Tuckahoe-1 | Sr. | 5-9 | 170 |
| DB | Tanner Bracchy, Delhi-4 | Sr. | 5-11 | 155 |
| DB | Joe Bauer, York/Pavilion-5 | Sr. | 6-3 | 175 |
| | | | | |
| | | | | |
| | Honorable Mention | | | |
| QB | Hudson Hunt (Sandy Creek-3, So.), Rory Farrell (Burke Catholic-9, Sr.) | | | |
| RB | Gavin McCabe (Warrensburg/Lake George/Bolton-2, Sr.), Tanner Trust (Pulaski-3, Sr.), Dan Trusdail (Newark Valley-4, Sr.), Carl Szczech (York/Pavilion-5, Sr.), Liam Grafton (Burke Catholic-9, Jr.) | | | |
| OE | Jackson Snyder (Tuckahoe-1, Sr.), Lennie Sitzer (Chatham-2, Sr.), Karson Sindoni (Tioga-4, Sr.), Quertin Center (Gowanda/Pine Valley-6) | | | |
| Line | Jack Hartman (Haldane-1, Sr.), Noah Davis (Greenwich-2, Sr.), Max Hohman (Warrensburg/Lake George/Bolton-2, Jr.), Adrian Lyon (Dolgeville-3, Sr.), Garrett Godfrey (Tioga-4, Jr.), Angelo Krzyston (Delhi-4), Cameron Rought (Tioga-4, Sr.), Ashton Bezon (Oakfield-Alabama/Elba-5, Sr.), Austin Pangrazio (Oakfield-Alabama/Elba-5, Sr.), Ryan Warner (Canisteo-Greenwood-5, Sr.), Maverick Adams (Randolph-6, Sr.), Devin Johnson (Clymer/Sherman/Panama-6, Sr.) | | | |
| LB | Erik Stubblefield (Haldane-1, Sr.), Robert Hazard (Beaver River-3, Sr.), Jack Williams (Westmoreland/Oriskany-3, Sr.), Sam Davis (Delhi-4), Wesley Farley (Avon-5, Jr.), Bodie Hyde (Oakfield-Alabama/Elba-5, Sr.), Brennan Royce (York/Pavilion-5, Sr.), Frankie Shaw (Burke Catholic-9, Sr.) | | | |
| DB | Ryan Ingber (Greenwich-2, So.), Gianni Silvestri (Tioga-4, Sr.), Jacek Teribury (Spencer-VanEtten/Candor-4, Sr.), Evan Fleury (Moriah-7) | | | |
| PK/P | Nick Romansky (Voorheesville-2, Sr.), Luke Nealis (Delhi-4, So.) | | | |
| | | | | |
| | | | | |
Want to help keep a good thing going? As a frequent visitor to this site, you know it is a leading source of news on high school sports across New York. You can help NewYorkSportswriters.org and its related sites by chipping in via PayPal or credit card.
