| | Player of the year: | Chris Nevinger, Letchworth-5, RB/LB | | | |
| | | 5-7, 175, Sr. | | | |
| | | | | | |
| | First-team offense | | | | |
| QB | Alex Grace | Maple Grove-6 | 5-9 | 165 | Sr. |
| RB | Saxon Smith | Chester-9 | 5-8 | 155 | Sr. |
| RB | Cody Bennett | Tioga-4 | 6-0 | 175 | Sr. |
| RB | Zeddie Williams | Silver Creek-6 | 6-2 | 190 | Jr. |
| RB | Brent Robbins | Randolph-6 | 5-9 | 180 | Sr. |
| OE | Will Bromirski | Cambridge-2 | 5-9 | 169 | Sr. |
| OE | Dalton Peterson | Frewsburg-6 | 6-2 | 190 | Sr. |
| OL | Shawn Stover | Chester-9 | | | Sr. |
| OL | Justin DiJulio | Walton-4 | 6-4 | 263 | Sr. |
| OL | Jake Remington | Letchworth-5 | 6-2 | 200 | Jr. |
| OL | David Waterman | Maple Grove-6 | 5-11 | 215 | Sr. |
| AP | Thad Johnson | Frewsburg-6 | 5-9 | 165 | Sr. |
| PK | Jason Pembridge | Maple Grove-6 | 6-0 | 180 | Sr. |
| | First-team defense | | | | |
| DL | Jordan Andrews | Letchworth-5 | 6-5 | 235 | Sr. |
| DL | Gary Moss | Tuckahoe-1 | 5-11 | 215 | Sr. |
| DL | Dan Lictus | Clymer-6 | 6-3 | 270 | Jr. |
| LB | Clifton Bacon | Letchworth-5 | 6-2 | 215 | Sr. |
| LB | Jon Cappetelli | Caledonia-Mumford-5 | 5-6 | 180 | Sr. |
| LB | John Nickerson | Maple Grove-6 | 6-0 | 210 | Sr. |
| LB | Billy Holden | Bainbridge-Guilford-4 | 6-2 | 225 | Sr. |
| LB | Ryan Borho | Ticonderoga-7 | 5-9 | 185 | Sr. |
| DB | Anthony Baxter | Onondaga-3 | 5-8 | 155 | Sr. |
| DB | Brandon Fuentes | Avon-5 | 5-8 | 162 | Sr. |
| DB | Ryan Owens | Letchworth-5 | 6-4 | 180 | Sr. |
| | | | | | |
| | Second-team offense | | | | |
| QB | Xavier Copeland | Geneseo-5 | 5-11 | 170 | Sr. |
| RB | Bryant Dain | Haldane-1 | 5-10 | 200 | Sr. |
| RB | Skyler Saunders | Cambridge-2 | 5-10 | 190 | Sr. |
| RB | Paul Wonka | Oxford-4 | 5-8 | 195 | Jr. |
| RB | Josh Hoagland | Whitehall-2 | 5-10 | 185 | Jr. |
| RB | Ryan Phelps | Clymer-6 | 5-10 | 195 | Sr. |
| OE | Skyler Liddle | Maple Grove-6 | 6-3 | 185 | Sr. |
| OE | Wes Smith | Geneseo-5 | 6-0 | 175 | Sr. |
| OL | Zach Diekel | Whitehall-2 | 6-0 | 195 | Sr. |
| OL | Cody Graczyk | Sherman-6 | 6-4 | 220 | Sr. |
| OL | Nick Talcott | Tioga-4 | | | Sr. |
| AP | Elias Lopez | Haldane-1 | 6-0 | 165 | Sr. |
| P | Robbie Stearns | Frewsburg-6 | 5-10 | 180 | Jr. |
| | Second-team defense | | | | |
| DL | Jeremy Stevens | Cambridge-2 | 6-0 | 246 | Sr. |
| DL | Marley Vil | Chester-9 | | | Sr. |
| LB | Nick Mitchell | Frewsburg-6 | 6-1 | 180 | Sr. |
| LB | Tyler Spires | Tioga-4 | | | Jr. |
| LB | Max Gorton | Dundee-5 | 6-0 | 215 | Sr. |
| LB | Mike McTarnaghan | Geneseo-5 | 5-9 | 175 | Sr. |
| LB | Chandler Baker | Chautauqua Lake-6 | 5-11 | 175 | Fr. |
| DB | Austin Ashby | Weedsport-3 | 6-2 | 180 | Sr. |
| DB | Nick Shiels | Walton-4 | 5-10 | 141 | Sr. |
| DB | Zack Pumputis | Avon-5 | 5-10 | 146 | Sr. |
| DB | John Jimerson | Silver Creek-6 | 5-9 | 150 | Sr. |
| | | | | | |
| | Third-team offense | | | | |
| QB | Colt Lowe | Portville-6 | 5-8 | 150 | Sr. |
| QB | Tom Manzella | Oakfield-Alabama-5 | 6-0 | 175 | Sr. |
| RB | Devon Walton | DeSales-5 | 5-10 | 185 | Sr. |
| RB | Chris Sampson | Chautauqua Lake-6 | 5-7 | 155 | Sr. |
| RB | Mike Beers | Walton-4 | 6-0 | 186 | Jr. |
| RB | Aaron Mulready | Cambridge-2 | 5-6 | 141 | Sr. |
| OE | Ben Langdon | Oakfield-Alabama-5 | 5-11 | 165 | Sr. |
| OE | Ryan Porter | Bainbridge-Guilford-4 | 6-4 | 210 | Sr. |
| OL | Dan Ognibene | Alexander-5 | 6-2 | 283 | Sr. |
| OL | Ben Dye | South Seneca-5 | 6-3 | 350 | Sr. |
| OL | Zach Schrader | West Canada Valley-3 | 6-3 | 270 | Sr. |
| OL | Derrek Jorgensen | Tioga-4 | | | Sr. |
| PK | Henry Heintzman | Haldane-1 | 6-3 | 210 | Sr. |
| | Third-team defense | | | | |
| DL | Nick Fisher | Chautauqua Lake-6 | 6-3 | 285 | Sr. |
| LB | Jared Frederick | Dolgeville-3 | 5-9 | 178 | Sr. |
| LB | James Moss | Haldane-1 | 5-7 | 190 | Sr. |
| LB | Ryan Murling | Westmoreland-3 | 6-2 | 175 | Sr. |
| LB | Ikeem Lyons | I-Prep-6 | 6-0 | 240 | Sr. |
| LB | Tyler Bishop | Rensselaer-2 | 5-8 | 200 | Sr. |
| DB | Marvin Sherman | Westmoreland-3 | 6-0 | 170 | Jr. |
| DB | Ray Ruggerio | Dolgeville-3 | 6-0 | 203 | Sr. |
| DB | Derek Fera | Lyons-5 | 5-10 | 170 | Sr. |
| DB | Paul Puddington | Beaver River-3 | 6-1 | 210 | Sr. |
| DB | Andrea Marsh | Panama-6 | 5-8 | 145 | Sr. |
| | | | | | |
Want to help keep a good thing going? As a frequent visitor to this site, you know it is a leading source of news on high school sports across New York. You can help NewYorkSportswriters.org and its related sites by chipping in via PayPal or credit card.
