First team-offense
E - Jimmer Bennett, sr., Albany Academy-2
E - Brandon Miles, sr., Oneida-3
L - Scott Wright, sr., Roosevelt-8
L - Chris Nocchi, sr., Waverly-4
L - Ryan Rossi, sr., Rye-1
L - Reggie Green, sr., Lackawanna-6
QB - Ryan Kramer, sr., Oneida-3
RB - Joe McMurry, sr., Hudson Falls-2
RB - Kyle Ramalho, sr., Rye-1
RB - Brendan Pidgeon, sr., Oneonta-4
RB - Capone Smith, sr., Lackawanna-6

First-team defense
L - Kivanc Tiyaloglu, sr., Locust Valley-8
L - Matt Gillmeister, sr., Oneida-3
L - Arlon Panizales, sr., Pleasantville-1
L - Will Jones, sr., Oneida-3
LB - Kevin Gorman, jr., Waverly-4
LB - Dan Fruscella, sr., Holland Patent-3
LB - Matt Schwartz, sr., Alden-6
LB - Dwayne Bennett, sr., Lackawanna-6
HB - Donald Keough, sr., Rye-1
HB - Jalon Edwards, sr., Roosevelt-8
S - Junior Collins, sr., Geneva-5

Second-team offense
E - Dan Ross, jr.,  Syracuse Westhill-3
E - Nick Peterson, sr., Medina-6
L - Shawn Shellenger, jr., Schalmont-2
L - Gabe Wittenberg, sr., Edgemont-1
L - Vaughn Labor, sr., Norwich-4
L - Don Rohauer, sr., Alden-6
QB - Neal Dotterer, sr., East Rochester/Gananda-5
RB - Eric Ippolito, sr., Fredonia-6
RB - Cole McCormack, jr., Rye-1
RB - Raymond Norman, sr., South Bronx-PSAL
RB - Brooks Estarfaa, sr., Maryvale-6

Second-team defense
L - Nick LaMountain, sr., Ravena-2
L - Mark Waite, sr., Schalmont-2
L - Jerrold Williams, sr., Lackawanna-6
L - Ethan Farabaugh, sr., Owego Free-4
LB - Sean Littlejohn, sr., Cohoes-2
LB - Cody Hutcheson, sr., Bath-5
LB - Matt McCabe, sr., Highland-9
LB - Brian Stinson, sr., Chenango Valley-4
HB - Pat O'Callaghan, sr., Rye-1
HB - Bobby Martin, sr., Geneva-5
S - Levin Pace, jr., Medina-6

Third-team offense
E - Shawn Dupuis, sr., Attica-5
E - Brandon Simonetta, sr., Homer-3
L - Tim Hammond, sr., Hudson Falls-2
L - Mike Tobin, sr., Burke Catholic-9
L - Nolan Haycook, sr., Chenango Forks-4
L - Nate Mattison, sr., Hudson Falls-2
QB - Will Fiacchi, jr., Marcellus-3
RB - Brandon Egan-Thorpe, sr., New Paltz-9
RB - Vince Gallo, jr., Schalmont-2
RB - Rocky Medeo, sr., Byram Hills-1
QB - Connor Eck, soph., Rye-1

Third-team defense
L - Kyle Collings, jr., Pioneer-6
L - Cole Hayes, sr., Malverne-8
L - Ken Betts, sr., Fredonia-6
L - Brian Moore, sr., Holland Patent-3
LB - Wade Kline, sr., Oneida-3
LB - Jonathan Manor, jr., Beekmantown-7
LB - Dan Cimino, sr., New Paltz-9
LB - T.C. Carroll, jr., Bath-5
LB - Rob Santangelo, sr., Rye-1
HB - Connor Kelleher, jr., Peru-7
S - Thann Akey, sr., Broadalbin-Perth-2