First-team offense
E - Marcus Sales, sr., Syracuse CBA-3
E - Joe Fazio, jr., West Genesee-3
L - Randy Bloom, sr., Orchard Park-6
L - Chris McHale, sr., Monroe-Woodbury-9
L - Nick Lepak, sr., Auburn-3
L - Jordany Diejuste, sr., Patchogue-Medford-11
QB - Tim Moran, sr., West Genesee-3
RB - Averin Collier, sr., Churchville-Chili-5
RB - Shaahiyn Alston, sr., Curtis-PSAL
RB - Kaheem Gist, sr., Canandaigua-5
RB - Brock Jackolski, sr., William Floyd-11

First-team defense
E - Jimmy Smith, sr., Canandaigua-5
E - Chandler Jones, sr., Union-Endicott-4
L - John Zoppo, sr., John Jay Cross River-1
L - Scott Vallone, sr., St. Anthony-CHSFL
L - Jared Veruto, jr., Union-Endicott-4
L - Steve Holness, sr., South Shore-PSAL
LB - Joe Leavell, sr., Orchard Park-6
LB - Alex Rivas, sr., East Meadow-8
LB - Christopher Thomas, sr., Curtis-PSAL
HB - Markell Rice, sr., New Rochelle-1
HB/K - Matt Hoey, sr., Auburn-3

Second-team offense
E - Jake Gurtler, sr., Orchard Park-6
E - Chris Alfano, jr., Iona Prep-CHSFL
L - Jonathan Heridan, sr., St. Joe by the Sea-CHSFL
L - Marco Scalia, sr., Monroe-Woodbury-9
L - Austen Fletcher, sr., St. Anthony-CHSFL
L - Joe Johnson, sr., William Floyd-11
QB - Joe Sidaras, sr., William Floyd-11
RB - Jeff Tundo, jr., Orchard Park-6
RB - Paris Walker, sr., New Rochelle-1
RB - Brandon Jones, sr., Canarsie-PSAL
QB - Dominick LeGrande, sr., Curtis-PSAL

Second-team defense
L - Luke Nawrocki, sr., Chaminade-CHSFL
L - Nick Condello, sr., Rush-Henrietta-5
L - Corey Balcerzak, sr., Lockport-6
L - Steve Dunn, sr., Churchville-Chili-5
L - Jeff Perez, sr., Iona Prep-CHSFL
LB - Dean Drehall, sr., Canarsie-PSAL
LB/K - Luke Cometti, sr., West Genesee-3
LB - Nick DePofi, sr., Union-Endicott-4
HB - Andrew Smith, sr., Guilderland-2
HB - Tim Moller, sr., East Islip-11
HB - Nate DeLone, sr., Rush-Henrietta-5

Third-team offense
E - Isai Reyes, sr., Warwick Valley-9
E - Jeff Falvey, sr., Cicero-North-Syracuse-3
L - Gary Chrys, sr., Niskayuna-2
L - Devin Van Auken, jr., Guilderland-2
L - Khalif Staten, sr., Abraham Lincoln-PSAL
QB - Dan Scalo, soph., Monroe-Woodbury-9
RB - Pat Brennan, sr., St. Joe by the Sea-CHSFL
RB - Greg Schuster, sr., Clarkstown North-1
RB - Colin Reno, sr., Scarsdale-1
RB - Laquan James, sr., Cicero-North Syracuse-3
QB - Ryan O'Neil, sr., Iona Prep-CHSFL

Third-team defense
E - Jesse Vavricka, jr., Minisink Valley-9
E - James Grande, sr., St. Joe by the Sea-CHSFL
L - Evan Russell, sr., Plainview JFK-8
L - Dan Kolinski, sr., West Genesee-3
L - Joe Silberzweig, sr., Scarsdale-1
LB - Matt Walker, sr., Newburgh Free-9
LB - Dave Colbert, sr., Curtis-PSAL
LB - Ray Marcano, sr., William Floyd-11
LB - Jim Schwendtner, sr., Shenendehowa-2
HB - Malcolm Campbell, sr., New Rochelle-1
S - Chris Bocklet, sr., John Jay Cross River-1

Fourth-team offense
E - Nate Papso, jr., Binghamton-4
E - T.J. Davis, sr., Liverpool-3
L - Steve Pooler, sr., West Genesee-3
L - Greg Van Roten, sr., Chaminade-CHSFL
L - Jermaine Endeley, sr., Curtis-PSAL
L - Dan Minahan, sr., Cicero-North Syracuse-3
QB - James Brady, sr., St. Anthony-CHSFL
RB - Marquis Terrell, jr., Troy LaSalle-2
RB - Chris Boyce, sr., Monroe-Woodbury-9
RB - Terrell Williams, jr., Hempstead-8
QB - Rob Calabrese, sr., East Islip-11

Fourth-team defense
L - Mike Riccione, sr., Fayetteville-Manlius-3
L - Thomas Oehm, jr., St. Joe by the Sea-CHSFL
L - Ramel Epps, sr., Freeport-8
L - Ken Perkins, sr., Bronx JFK-PSAL
LB - Pete Stanish, sr., Guilderland-2
LB - Chris Cook, sr., Vestal-4
LB - Ricky Palmer, sr., Brentwood-11
LB - Jonathan Rossi, sr., Buffalo St. Joe-CHSAA
HB - Steve Ianzito, sr., Cicero-North Syracuse-3
HB - Luke Tasker, jr., Buffalo St. Francis-CHSAA
HB/K - J.K. Filauro, sr., John Jay Cross River-1
K - Jamie Boyle, jr., Monroe-Woodbury-9