All players are seniors unless otherwise noted.

First offense
E -- Bryan Tornee, Commack-11
E -- Azariah Sangster, Henninger-3
L -- Shawn Williamson, Jamestown-6
L --  Dave Archer, Union-Endicott-4
L  -- John Martinelli, Centereach-11
QB-- Mike Prahalis, Commack-11
RB-- Jazzmen Williams, Pittsford-5
RB-- Ramael Myers, Susan Wagner-NYC
RE-- Terry Butler, Henninger-3
RB-- Aaron Leeper, Jamestown-6 (player of the year)
KR-- Steve Gregory, Curtis-NYC

First defense
E -- Anthony Canty, Troy-2
L  -- Craig Akins, Webster-5
L  -- Sheldon Battle, Jamestown-6
L  -- Leon Williams, Canarsie-NYC
L  -- Alex Shafiro, New Rochelle-1
LB-- Clint Riggs, Commack-11
LB-- Guiseppe Aguanno, Msgr. Farrell
LB-- Eddie Gordon, Freeport-8
LB-- Aaron Sanders, St. Joe-CHS-6
HB-- Chris Richez, Freeport-8
HB-- Ty Godinho, Lancaster-6

Second offense
E --   Jamel Richardson, Corcoran-3
E -- Brian Nutter, Sachem-11
L  -- Matt Nobles, Bishop Maginn-2
L -- Ben Lazarski, Newburgh Free-9
L -- Carl Harding, North Rockland-1
E -- Jonathan Williams, Irondequoit-5
QB-- Jason Quarterman, New Rochelle-1
QB-- Bobby Seck, Bishop Kellenberg-CHS
RB-- Frank Lazio, St. Anthony-CHS
RB-- Devron Fallen, Bishop Maginn-2
RB-- Jason Sullivan, Msgr. Farrell-CHS

Second defense
E -- Muttagi Windley, Bronx JFK-NYC
L -- Erick Calkins, Baldwinsville-3
L -- Bart Napier, Jamestown-6
L -- Andy Manacchio, Clarence-6
LB-- Dantae Ransom, Columbus-NYC
LB-- Nino Othman, Syosset-8
LB-- Manuel Tapia, Niskayuna-2
HB-- Ashton Scaccia, Webster-5
HB-- R.J. Harvey, Colonie-2
HB-- Allen Zemaitis, Spencerport-5
S -- Craig Georgalas, Mahopac-1

Third offense
E -- Dave Sanok, St. Francis-CHS-6
E -- Jaishon Banks, New Rochelle-1
L -- Christian Ricciardi, Tottenville-NYC
L -- Joe Scalice, North Tonawanda-6
L -- Dequay Shoulders, Syracuse Corcoran-3 
QB-- Greg Rommel, Syracuse Henninger-3, jr.
RB-- Chris Nappi, Niskayuna-2 
RB-- Andrew Grant, Baldwinsville-3 
RB-- Joe Loscalzo, New Rochelle-1 
RB-- Erik Zorich, North Tonawanda-6 
K --  Mike Baker, Jamestown-6

Third defense
E/K- Zack Whiting, St. Joe-CHS-6
L  -- James Prusinowski, Bald'ville-3
L  -- Phil Rossomando, Msgr. Farrell-CHS
L  -- Justin Laurienzo, Lancaster-6, jr.
LB-- Bob Alpi, North Babylon-11
LB-- Brian Becker, Saratoga-2
LB-- Greg Keller, Rome Free-3
HB-- Chris Stokstad, Union-Endicott-4
HB-- Ricky Gonzalez, Jamestown-6
HB-- Nick Woll, Walt Whitman-11
S  -- Sean Treasure, Baldwin-8

Fourth offense
E -- Gary Ham, Susan Wagner-NYC
E -- Kenny Hooks, Webster-5
L -- Greg Scalo, Monroe-Woodbury-9 
L -- Mike Schifano, Webster-5 
L -- Dwayne Shaw, Syracuse Henninger-3  
L -- Padley Delide, Ramapo-1
QB-- Jeff Krieger, Webster-5
QB-- Matt DeBlasio, Monroe-Woodbury-9, jr.
RB-- Chris Legette, Gates Chili-5 
RB-- Jolonn Dunbar, Syracuse Corcoran-3, soph.
RB-- Adebayo Adedapo, New Utrecht-NYC 

Fourth offense
L -- Brian Carstens, Msgr. Farrell-CHS 
L -- Mike Pellett, Union-Endicott-4   
L -- Michael Barbara, Spring Valley-1
LB-- Lee Boos, Susan Wagner-NYC  
LB-- Jose Colon, Utica Proctor-3  
LB-- Elliot Goode, Fayetteville-Manlius-3, jr.
LB-- Mike Norelli, Colonie-2 
HB-- Jason Kendrick, Union-Endicott-4 
HB-- Taurean Frazier, Hempstead-8  
HB-- Chris McDuffie, Williamsville North-6. jr.
S -- Hubert Hanks, Liverpool-3