All players are seniors unless otherwise noted.

First offense
E  -- Brandon Sebald, Rondout Valley-9 (player of the year)
E  -- Dave Ponza, Solvay-3
L   -- Jeff Haruthunian, Bethpage-8
L   -- Josh LaGrow, Syracuse CBA-3
L   -- Randall James, Roosevelt-8
L   -- Tim Conley, Albion-6
QB -- Joe Casamento Jr.. Syracuse CBA-3
RB -- Nelvin Wilder, Lackawanna-6
RB -- Pat Rahm, Rondout Valley-9
RB -- Eugene Nottingham, Amityville-11
RB -- Brandon Munson, Albion-6

First defense
E   -- James Wyche, Roosevelt-8
E   -- Ron Foster, Peru-7
L   -- Peter Lofaso, Chenango Forks-4
L   -- Emilio Pena, Lackawanna-6
L   -- Cory Kilpatrick, Elmira Notre Dame-4
LB -- Dion Jones, Lackawanna-6
LB -- Craig Romano, Solvay-3
LB -- Scott Cronin, Hudson Falls-2
HB -- Matt Rewkowski, Bethpage-8
HB -- E.J. Jackson, Syracuse CBA-3
S   -- Drew Peters, Babylon-11, jr.

Second offense
E  -- Nick Tillman, Sus. Valley-4
E  -- Rob Meyer, Peru-7
L  -- Brian Mullaney, Somers-1
L  -- Ben Wiley, V-V-Sherrill-3
L  -- Tony Sakellariou, Rondout Valley-9
L   -- Matt Nelson, Glens Falls-2
QB-- Darmel Whitfield,  Buffalo Seneca-6
RB-- Joe Kugler, Somers-1-
RB-- Anwau Huffman, Manhasset-8
RB-- Brandon Ashraf, Olean-6
RB-- Mark Rossi, Oneida-3

Second defense
E  -- Brian Pawlowski, Clarke-8
E  -- Greg Suhr, Bethpage-8
L  -- Kelsey Jenks, Chenango Forks-4, soph.
L  -- Nick DeFeo, Syracuse CBA-3
LB-- Teru Branch, Maine-Endwell -4
LB-- Ryan Conklin, Nanuet-1
LB— Jeff McGill, Cheektowaga-6
LB-- Rod Richardson, Lackawanna-6, soph.
BB-- John Russ, Honeoye Falls-Lima-5, jr.
BB-- Dave Daniels, Elmira Notre Dame-4
S  -- Ryan Smith, Tonawanda-6, jr.

Third offense
E --  Jeff Vossler, Saranac Lake-7
E --  Mike DiRienzo, East Aurora-6
L --  Jared Lackie, Ravena-2
L --  Dan Alongi, Midlakes-5
L --  Tom Kasmierczak, Depew-6 , jr.
L --  Jason Bryden, B-G-Afton-4
QB-- Todd Acchione, Solvay-3
RB-- Jason Berghold, Depew-6
RB-- Matt Winseman, Sus. Valley-4
RB-- John Stevens, B-G-Afton-4
RB-- Jake Plunkett Homer-3

Third defense
E  -- Jason Horn, Springville-6
E   -- Chris Gadway, Beekmantown-7
L   -- Darrell Glover, Lackawanna-6, soph.
L   -- Justin Washingon, Olean-6
LB -- Jeff Toombs, Marlboro-9
LB -- Matt Dupuis, Corning East-4
LB -- Bryan Steele, Hudson Falls-2
LB -- Brett Reynolds, Glens Falls-2
HB -- Chris McGrath, Nanuet-1
HB -- Luke Reilly, Corning East-4
S   -- Anthony Pollizi, Hornell-5