All players are seniors unless otherwise noted.

First offense
E -- Marc Miranda, Mechanicville-2
E -- David Stanton, Walton-4, jr.
L -- Tim Foley, Briarcliff-1
L -- Mike Martin, Walton-4
L -- Vinny Fuschetto, Westlake-1
L -- Alex Bernstein, Edgemont-1, jr.
QB -- Marc Saracino, Rye-1
RB -- Matt Bernstein, Edgemont-1 (player of the year)
RB -- Eric Everett, Cleveland Hill-6
RB -- Eric Mitchell, Bishop Ludden-3
RB -- Brian Leonard, Gouverneur-10, jr.

First defense
E -- Dan Mangiero, Poly Prep-NYC
E/K -- Joe Rogers, Bishop Ludden-3, jr.
L -- Aaron Kimball, Fonda-2
L -- Rob Schroeder, East Rochester-5
L -- Lou Funaro, Mechanicville-2
LB -- Matt Van Alst, LeRoy-5
LB -- Anthony Jeffries, Allegany-Limestone-6
LB -- Harris Sarraf, Edgemont-1
DB -- Troy Anderson, Caledonia-Mumford-5
DB -- Joe Tarasiewicz, Edgemont-1
S -- Johnny Chen, Edgemont-1

Second offense
E -- Kyle Collins, Fonda-2
E -- Rick Luchetta, Delhi-4
L -- Adam Burr, Cambridge-2, jr.
L -- Jason Wrisley, Sauquoit Valley-3
L -- Quincy Reid, Malverne-8
QB -- Chris Legree, Poly Prep-NYC
QB -- Kyle Lauver, Cambridge-2
RB -- Duane Moore, Elmira Heights Edison-4
RB -- Kyle Miller, LeRoy-5
RB -- Kevin Mullally, Sullivan West-9, jr.
RB -- Mike Tribelhorn, Locust Valley-8

Second defense
E -- Ian Smart, Ausable Valley-7
E -- Tim Hegarty, Briarcliff-1
L -- Antwon Burton, Cleveland Hill-6
L -- Bill Andrews, Edgemont-1, soph.
LB -- Dustin Ross, Salamanca-6, jr.
LB -- Brian Dewey, Schuylerville-2
LB -- Mark Burrell, Ausable Valley-7
LB -- Tim Lutgens, Greenwich-2
HB -- Cameron Haines, Salamanca-6, jr.
HB -- Matt Townsend, Cambridge-2
S -- Casey Hilpert, Hackley School-1

Third offense
E -- Aaron Smith, Highland Falls O'Neil-9
E -- Rayshawn Bolden, Cheektowaga JFK-6, jr.
L -- Matt Birmingham, Hackley School-1
L -- E.T. Toledo, Sullivan West-9, jr.
L -- John Williams, Oakfield-Alabama-5
QB -- Mike Mancini, Fonda-2, jr.
QB -- Myron Lee, Cleveland Hill-6
QB -- Ben Brown, Dalton School-NYC
RB -- Marcus Wilson, Poly Prep-NYC
RB -- Adam Williams, Lowville-3, soph.
RB -- Artie Viggiano, Pelham-1

Third defense
E -- Kyle Scott, Salamanca-6
E -- Joe Boulukos, Cold Spring Harbor-8, jr.
L -- Jason Kruger, Fonda-2
L -- Pat Colantuono, Irvington-1
LB -- Brian Neale, Delhi-4, jr.
LB -- Charlie Praid, Rye-1
LB -- Brett Cardillo, Sauquoit Valley-3
HB -- Marc Lavigne, Tupper Lake-7
HB -- Jon Blumhagen, Nichols School-6
HB -- Todd Eyler, Rye-1
S -- Steve Jarmuz, St. Mary-6-CHS