All players are seniors unless otherwise noted.

First offense
E -- Jacob Shields, Panama-6
E -- Marcus Eriksson, Onondaga-3
I -- Ed Stallman, Dolgeville-3
I -- Derrick Casler, Maple Grove-6
I -- Albert Russo, Tuckahoe-I
L -- Colt Harness, Ellicottville-6
QB -- Jamie Miller, Dolgeville-3 (co-player of the year)
RB    Audwin Davis Jr., Tuckahoe-1
RB -- Carl Althans, Ellicottville-6, jr.
RB -- Jason Barnes, Dolgeville-3
RB-K- Mike Chrystie, Oxford-4 (co-player of the year)

First defense
E -- Bill Petry, East Rockaway-8
E/K -- Jordan Rambacher, Maple Grove-6, jr.
L -- Tim McGuire, Mohawk-3
L -- Zack Monforte, Warrensburg-2
L -- Paul Hart, Oriskany-3, jr.
LB -- Kurtis Mowers, Dolgeville-3
LB -- Damn Venne, Moriah-7
LE -- Aaron Barton, Panama-6
HB -- Kyle Grantling, Clyde-Savannah-5
HB -- Mike Darling, Maple Grove-6, jr.
S -- Frank Kelly, East Rockaway-8

Second offense
E -- Brendan Hackett, Haldane-1
E -- Colin Ray, Hamilton-3
L -- Brian Pino, Fort Edward-2
L -- Peter Williamson, Friends-8
L -- William Waxman, East Rockaway-8
QB -- Tom Gaddor, Moriah-7, jr.
RB -- Jehuu Caulcrick, Clymer-6, soph.
RB -- Brian Bach, Weedsport-3, jr.
RB -- Kyle Sylstra, Oxford-4
RB -- Mike Hart, Onondaga-3, fr.
RB -- A.J. Malecki, Clymer-6, jr.

Second defense
L -- Jeremy Parker, Weedsport-3, jr.
L -- Garrett Kline, Sandy Creek-3, jr.
L -- Josh Serow, Dolgeville-3
LB -- Frank Carlson, Tuckahoe-1
LB -- Brandon Yarnes, Oxford-4, jr.
LB -- Mark Daniels, Valhalla-1
HB -- Jeff Caprood, Fort Edward-2
HB -- Greg Anderson, Haldane-1
HB -- Brian Hall, Dolgeville-3
HB -- Phil Reda, Pawling-1, jr.
S -- Kevin Clarkin, Rome Catholic-3