All players are seniors unless otherwise noted.

First offense
E--Joe Holden, Wantagh-8
E--Maurice Lobdell, Syracuse CBA-3
L--Kevin Moodt, Bellport-11
L--Josh Beekman, Amsterdam-2
L--Ted Rene, Nyack-1, jr.
L--Brandon McInerney, Syracuse CBA-3, jr.
QB--Mark Magliocco Jr., Rochester Aquinas-5 (player of the year)
RB--Matt Murray, Horace Greeley-1, jr.
RB--Calvin Hall, Rochester Aquinas-5, jr.
RB--Bryant Daniels, Rockville Centre Southside-8
RB--Jeff Wolf, Williamsville East-6
 
First defense
E--William Leone, Nyack-1, jr.
L--Matt Pollock, Fulton-3
L--Mike Molloy, Bellport-11
L--Jon Andriac, Port Jervis-9
E--Steve Makovich, Burnt Hills-2
LB--Tim Lee, Syracuse CBA-3
LB--Eric Neugebauer, Sayville-11
LB--Jeff Hahn, Warwick Valley-9
HB--Nigel Morris, Nyack-1, jr.
HB--Nick Parisi, Buffalo Timon-6-CHS
S--Stephen Sair, Huntington-11

Second offense
E--Chris Martocchia, Wantagh-8
E--Kevin McMahan, Rochester Aquinas-5
L--Cody Ashe, South Glens Falls-2
L--Matt Polseinello, Troy LaSalle-2
L--William Dortch, Spring Valley-1
E--Derrick Valentine, St. Peter-NYC-CHS
QB--Greg Paulus, Syracuse CBA-3, fr.
RB--Craig Fitzpatrick, Fulton-3
RB--Pat Walsh, Wantagh-8
RB--Arel Gordon, Rochester Aquinas-5, jr.
RB--Benny Curry, Syr. Fowler-3

Second defnse
E--Damien Gilyard, Elmont-8
L--Charlie Mayrer, Troy LaSalle-2
L--Nick DeFeo, Syracuse CBA-3, jr.
L--Tim Schmidt, Owego Free-4
LB--Kevin Flike, Troy LaSalle-2
LB--Mick Canevari, Warwick Valley-9
LB--Jon Hall, Pioneer-6
HB--Mike Allen, Fulton-3
HB--Nathan Gibbons, Batavia-5
HB--Topher Davey, Amsterdam-2
S--Brian Rath, Wantagh-8

Third offense
E--Sean Jemison, Rochester Aquinas-5
E--Mark Rubin, Amherst-6, soph.
L--Travis Lake, Chittenango-3
L--Stan Prescott, Mohonasen-2
L--Jeremy Kozak, New Hartford-3
QB--Rob Felicetta, Bellport-11, jr.
RB--Derrick Beckworth, Elmira Free-4, soph.
RB--Josh Anderson, East Syracuse-Minoa-3
RB--Tyler Nugent, White Plains Stepinac-1
RB--Josh Perkins, Niagara-Wheatfield-6, jr.
RB--Emmanuel Marc, Spring Valley-1

Third defense
E--Michael Quick, Port Jervis-9, jr.
L--Chris Paulus, Syracuse CBA-3, jr.
E--Mac Bowen, Horace Greeley-1
LB--Derek Wayman, Burnt Hills-2
LB--Darwin Powell, Harborfields-11
LB--Matt Zando, Carthage-3
LB--Terry Benton, Grand Island-6
HB--Anthony Evans, Nyack-1
HB--Brandon Holtslag, Whitesboro-3
HB--Owen Messner, East Islip-11
S--Jason Cappadoro, MacArthur-8