All players are seniors unless otherwise noted.

First offense
E -- Mike Oertel, Peru-7
E -- Matt St. Clair, Peru-7
L -- Juan Mendoza, Chenango Forks-4 
L -- Brennan Bezon, Albion-6 
L -- Andrew Weininger, Harrison-1 
L -- Jim Lee, Olean-6 
QB -- Matt Bezio, Peru-7 
RB -- Rudy Arcara, Harrison-1
RB -- Kelsey Jenks, Chenango Forks-4 (player of the year)
RB -- Kevin Hillman, Seaford-8 
RB -- Mark Rohinson, Bath-5

First defense
E -- John Carroll, Bethpage-8 
E -- Ricky Alvarado, Harrison-1 
L -- Jake Frisch, Chenango Forks-4 
L -- Bill Andrews, Edgemont-1 
L -- Nick Moore, Peru-7
LB -- Trevon Roaney, Babylon-11
LB -- Jake Wittenberg, Edgemont-1 
LB -- Jon Winston, Nanuet-1
HB -- James Wright, Olean-6 
HB -- Jmnison Koesterer, Cazenovia-3
S -- Jamie Romano, Solvay-3, jr.

Second offense
E -- Derek Kinder, Albion-6, jr.
E -- Mike Wall, Solvay-3
L -- Tim Halvorsen, Babylon-11 
L -- Mike Breznicky, Eastchester-l, jr.
L -- Stefan Ifasi, Bethpage-8 
L -- Lonnie Simmons, Solvay-3, jr.
E -- Anthony DeMatteo, Somers-1
QB -- Peter Kohlasch, Harrison-l 
RB -- Kareem Jones, Lansingburgh-2, jr. 
RB -- Jordan Rabidou, Somers-1 
RB -- Stan Grobsmith, Solvay-3

Second defense
E -- Shonte Freeman, Lansingburgh-2 
E -- Travis O'Dell, New Paltz-9
L -- Garrett Lang, Bath-5, jr.
L -- Chris Fee, Ogdensburg Free-10 
LB -- Mike Bassage, Hornell-5
LB -- Ryan Blessing, Oneida-3, jr.
LB -- Ryan Lenihan, White Plains Stepinac-1
LB -- John Benson, Gouverneur-l0 
HB -- Chris Hoffman, Cazenovia-3, jr.
HB -- Paul Izzo, Cohoes-2
S -- Marcel Youngs, Lansingburgh-2 

Third offense
E -- Ravi Kantha, Fordham Prep-NYC
E -- Zach Tarnowski, Chenango Forks-4
L -- Mike Stuart, Cobleskill-2
L -- John Rescott, Lansingburgh-2, jr.
L -- Thad Loomis, Norwich-4
L -- Bob Perrault, Lansingburgh-2
QB -- Erik Jansen, Bethpage-8
QB -- Rob Kramer, Oneida-3, jr.
RB -- Greg Sargent, Ogdensburg Free-10 
RB -- Ryan Goetz, Elmira Notre Dame-4, jr.
RB -- Sean Nowicki, Alden-6 

Third defense
E -- Kyle Worley, Cheektowaga-6 
L -- Paul Garcia, Solvay-3, jr.
L -- Zack Middleton, Hudson Falls-2
L -- Zach Johnson, Olean-6
LB -- Amsey Remchuk, Bath-5, jr.
LB -- Bubba Newsome, Albion-6
LB -- Juan Morales, Spackenkill-9, jr.
LB -- Matt McGrath, Lansingburgh-2, jr.
HB -- Geoff Bean, Oneonta-4
HB -- Adam Wojdyla, Depew-6
S -- Matt Juriga, Chenango Forks-4