All players are seniors unless otherwise noted.

First offense
E -- Brendan Fulmer, LeRoy-5
E -- Justin Alexander, Cambridge-2 
L -- Kurt Wasilewski, Onondaga-3 
L -- Jon Mahler, Riverdale-NYC 
L -- Jake Syracuse, LeRoy-5 
L -- Paul Harnas, Elmira T. Edison-4 
QB -- Rob Higle, Briarcliff-l 
RB -- Mike Hart, Onondaga-3, jr. (player of the year)
RB -- Nick Alena, Lyons-5 
RB -- Corey Graham, Turner-Carroll-6 
RB -- James Reile, Herkimer-3 

First defense
E -- Charles Wilson, Poly Prep-NYC 
E -- Jake Cummings, Onondaga-3 
L -- Don Miller, LeRoy-5 
L -- James Coughlin, Walton-4 
E -- Matt Darby, Westlake-l 
LB -- Kyle Martin, Onondaga-3 
LB -- Mark Hermann, Hackley-l 
LB -- Dusty Andrus, Greene-4 
HB -- Joe Shaughnessy, LeRoy-5 
HB -- Ben Schori, Riverdale-NYC 
HB/K -- Bob Blevins, Briarcliff-l 

Second offense
E -- Hodges Sneed, Onondaga-3, jr.
E -- Marcus Stanford, Bishop Gibbons-2 
L -- Alan Searles, Lansing-4 
L -- Matt Manchester, Hastings-1, jr. 
L -- Dan Willis, Onondaga-3 
L -- Diavalo Fletcher, Tupper Lake-7, jr.
QB -- John Polignone, Poly Prep-NYC 
RB -- Vince Marzano, Mechanicville-2 
RB -- Dan Lopez, St. Mary-6-CHS 
RB -- Brandon Paulus, Pleasill1tville-l 
RB -- Kelly Gordon, Ausable Valley-7 

Second defense
E -- Dan Riehle, Gowanda-6 
L -- Nick Delap, Watervliet-2
L -- Rob Vaccaro, Pleasantville-l 
L -- Matt Krauss, Cassadaga Valley-6
L -- Kevin Sullivan, Mechanicville-2 
LB -- Ira Smith, Lyons-5
LB -- Marco DeRose, Briarcliff-1
LB -- Nate Siegal, Riverdale-NYC
LB -- Tim Clare, Lansing-4
HB -- Justin Graham, Onondaga-3
HB -- Tom Palcic, Gowanda-6

Third offense
E -- Mike Zmuda, Gowanda-6
L -- John Tomlin, Briarcliff-1, jr.
L -- Erick Tylutki, Fonda-2
L -- John Zielinski, Caledonia-Mumford-5
L -- Mike Bauer, Silver Creek-6
L -- Bill Hribar, Cooperstown-3, jr.
QB -- Chad Wysocki, Hoosick Falls-2, jr.
QB -- Zack Luke, Cambridge-2, soph.
RB -- Adam Hellwig, Portville-6
RB -- Mike Gisondi, Westlake-1
RB -- Lucas Macariello, Schuylerville-2

Third defense
E -- Joe Trama, Irvington-1, jr.
E -- Mike Fahy, Albertus Magnus-1
L -- Doug Worthington, Turner-Carroll-6, soph.
L -- Carl Runge, Onondaga-3, jr.
L -- Luke Robbins, Tioga-4
LB -- Mike Liberatore, Salamanca-6 
LB -- Jason Fish, Ticonderoga-7
LB -- Brian Macri, Herkimer-3
LB -- Kirk Fletcher, Walton-4, jr.
LB -- Brian Harrington, Cambridge-2
HB -- Dustin Towers, Falconer-6