All players are seniors unless otherwise noted.

First offense
E -- Tremaine Moore, Syracuse Corcoran-3
E -- Rich Pennecke, Holy Trinity-CHSFL
L -- Alex Fletcher, St. Anthony-CHSFL 
L -- Andre Douglas, New Rochelle-1 
L -- Justin Schifano. Webster Schroeder-5, jr.
L -- Jerome Chambers, Lockport-6 
QB -- Greg Paulus, Syracuse CBA-3, jr.
RB -- Matt Hahn, St. Anthony-CHSFL (co-player of the year)
RB -- Jhamal Fluellen, Lockport-6 
RB -- Ray Rice, New Rochelle-l, jr. (co-player of the year)
RB -- Jason Gwaltney, North Babylon-ll, jr.

First defense
E -- Nick Santiago, Utica Proctor-3 
L -- Rich Ohrnberger, East Meadow-8 
L -- Jason Diehl, Troy-2 
L -- Matt Graham, Orchard Park-6 
L -- Arthur Jones, Union-Endicott-4, jr.
LB -- Evan McGuire, White Plains-l 
LB -- JOn Pitt-Coombs, Tottenvil1e-NYC 
LB -- Stan Gutierrez, Freeport-8 
HB -- Jason Downey, Shenendehowa-2 
HB-- Spencer Ridenhour, White Plains-l 
S -- Mike Kaplun, Webster Schroeder-5 

Second offense
E -- Sean Bergin, Newburgh Free-9 
E -- Erik Reitmayr, Freeport-8 
E -- Bruce Williams, Syracuse CBA-3, jr.
L -- Izzy Daiuta, Poly Prep-NYC 
L -- Phil Byers, Gates Chili-5 
L -- Dusty Connelly, Shenendehowa-2 
QB -- Aubrey Norris, Port Richmond-NYC 
QB -- Randy Mills, Freeport-8 
RB -- Mike Stenclik, Webster Schroeder-5, jr.
RB -- Joe Williams, Newburgh Free-9 
RB -- Tyler Zeronda, Shenendehowa-2

Second defense
E -- James Parker, William FLoyd-11
L -- Maheen Harris, Poly Prep-NYC
L -- Mike Savage, New Rochelle-1
L -- Mike Keigh, Riverhead-11
L -- Doug Worthington, St. Francis-6-CHSFL, jr.
L  -- Bemi Otulaja, Freeport-8
LB -- Joe Battaglia, Syracuse CBA-3
LB -- John Fruschino, Shenendehowa-2
LB -- Scooter Berry, North Babylon-11, jr.
HB -- Cody Williams, Orchard Park-6
S/K -- Ed Wallace, Columbia-2

Third offense
E -- Lavar Lobdell, Syracuse CBA-3, jr.
E -- Jeremy Brown, Lockport-6
L -- Frank Leon, North Rockland-1
L -- Tyrell Ford, Syracuse Corcoran-3
L -- Chris Smith, St. Francis-6-CHSFL, jr.
L -- Darnell Gilet, North Rockland-l 
QB -- Tim Sheard, Syracuse Corcoran-3 
RB -- Josh Amaro, Msgr. Farrell-NYC 
RB -- Matt Ward, Utica Proctor-3
RB -- Anthony McCoy, North Rockland-l 
RB -- Brandon Sykes, Rochester Edison~5 

Third defense
E -- Chris McClurg, Webster Schroeder-·5 
L -- Steve Cuff, Newburgh Free-9 
L -- Alex Haney, Lockport-6
L -- Jason Weber, Orchard Park-6, jr.
LB -- Joe Russo, Utica Proctor-3, jr.
LB -- Brett Maher, North Rockland-l 
LB -- Matt Scalise, North Tonawanda-6, jr.
HB -- Datwan Hemingway, Albany CBA-2 
HB -- Mark Schaller, Greece Athena-5 
HB -- Pasquale Raimondo, St. Francis-6-CHSFL
S/K -- Tom Manning, Rome Free Academy--3, jr.

Fourth offense
E -- Nick Testo, Troy-2 
E -- Greg Deptula, Suffern~l 
E -- Rick Palermo, Webster Thomas-5 
L -- Kevin Thie, St, Francis-6-CHSFL 
L -- James Basile, Albany-2
L -- Rob Lunn, Penfield-5 
QB -- Joe Zaccardo, Webster Thomas-5, jr.
QB -- Matt Stack, Monroe-Woodbury-9, jr.
RB -- Mike Mancini, Auburn-3
RB -- Morgan Hall, Ramapo-l, jr.
RB -- James Mallory, Kenmore West-6, jr.

Fourth defense
E -- Jeremy Riley, Union-Endicott-4 
L -- Kevin Richards, Shenendehowa-2, jr.
L -- Mike Paolucci, Vestal-4
LB -- Shawn Schneider, Liverpool-3
LB -- Andy Barone, Hamburg Frontier-6
HB -- Rahoo Walker, Hempstead-8, jr.
HB -- Jason Butler, Syracuse Henninger-3
HB -- Courtney Greene, New Rochelle-l
HB -- Rory Pedrick, Saratoga-2
HB -- DOug Fulmer, Syracuse Henninger-3, jr.
S/K -- Brian Nelson, Shenendehowa-2, jr.