First team-offense
E - Kevin Ogletree, Holy Cross-NYC, sr.
E - Matt Carrigg, Maine-Endwell-4, sr.
L - Pete D'Aguanno, Fox Lane-1, sr.
L - Chris Conklin, Port-Jervis-9, sr.
L - Stan Belice, Spring Valley-1, sr.
L - Devin McLoughlin, Iona Prep-1, sr.
QB - Shane Connolly, Maine-Endwell-4
RB - Terry Baltimore, Nyack-1, sr.
RB - John DeLuca, Sayville-11, sr.
RB - Steve Mamak, Iroquois-6, sr.
RB - Derrick Hairston, Carthage-3, sr.

First-team defense
E - Greg Daly, Garden City-8, sr.
E - Matt Reardon, Bethpage-8, sr.
L - Mike Condon, Victor-5, sr.
L - Anthony Dufresne, Amsterdam-2, sr.
LB - Trevor Pedrick, Wallkill-9, sr.
LB - Terence Hartigan, Garden City-8, sr.
LB - Ken Johnson, Sweet Home-6, sr.
LB - Darrell Young, Amityville-11, sr.
HB - Tim Rice, Maine-Endwell-4, sr.
HB - T.J. Czeski, Amsterdam-2, jr.
S / K - Adolfo Rivera, Wallkill-9, sr.

Second-team offense
E - Anthony Muscarella, Wantagh-8, sr.
E - Steve Hurtgam, Lewiston-Porter-6, sr.
L - Mike Jean-Baptiste, Nyack-1, sr.
L - Tom Baileys, Owego Free-4, sr.
L - Sean Connors, Walkill-9, sr.
L - Ian Margerum, Lake Shore-6, sr.
QB - Alex Relph, Victor-5, sr.
RB - Bobby Taylor, Whitesboro-3, sr.
RB - J.J. Maloney, Walkill-9, sr.
RB - Aaron Johnson, Spring Valley-1, sr.
QB - Dan Pitcher, Cortland-3, sr.

Second-team defense
E - Ian Assrel, Hewlett-8, jr.
E - Adriel Santiago, South Park-6, sr.
L - Matt Gartler, Iroquois-6, jr.
L - Matt Colucci, Queensbury-2, sr.
LB - Anthony Arena, Bethpage-8, sr.
LB - Jay Colabella, Harrison-1, sr.
LB - Matt Driscoll, Lake Shore-6, sr.
LB - Bill Watson, Fulton-3, sr.
HB - Max Seibald, Hewlett-8, sr.
HB - Kyle Brown, Bishop Maginn-2, sr.
S - Tony DeSantis, Queensbury-2, sr.

Third-team offense
E - Derrick Woodard, Whitesboro-3, sr.
E - Rob Gomez, Wallkill-9, jr.
L - Sean Flynn, Whitesboro-3. sr.
L - P.J. Colombo, Wallkill-9, sr.
L - Dan Pollock, Fulton-3, sr.
L - Andy Cottet, Jamesville-DeWitt-3, sr.
QB - Nick Doscher, Moore Catholic-NYC, sr.
RB - Stephon Jones, Indian River-10, sr.
RB - Brandon Corp, Chittenango-3, sr.
RB - John Foley, Port Jervis-9, sr.
QB - Kyle Auffray, Cornwall-9, sr.

Third-team defense
E - Mike Meta, Maine-Endwell-4, sr.
E - Lazarus Tucker, Indian River-10, sr.
L - Ben St. Andrew, Queensbury-2, sr.
L - William Boone, Moore Catholic-NYC, sr.
L - Kurt Norton, Sayville-11, sr.
LB - Dan Smith, Whitesboro-3, sr.
LB - Vidal Hazelton, Moore Catholic-NYC, jr.
LB - Michael Procida, Wantagh-8, sr.
HB - Tom Marino, Garden City-8, sr.
HB - Nate Matusick, Corning East-4, sr.
S / QB - Jimmy Robertson, Iona Prep-1, sr.