First team-offense
E - Bruce Williams, Syracuse CBA-3, sr.
E - Lavar Lobdell, Syracuse CBA-3, sr.
L - Justin Schifano, Webster Schroeder-5, sr.
L - Chris Pugliese, Patchogue-Medford-11, sr.
L - Steve Fulfree, St. Anthony-CHSFL, sr.
L - John Cinelli, Farmingdale-8, sr.
QB - Greg Paulus, Syracuse CBA-3, sr.
RB - Ray Rice, New Rochelle-1, sr.
RB - Jason Gwaltney, North Babylon-11, sr.
RB - Zak Kedron, St. Francis-CHSFL-6, sr.
RB - P.J. Hill, Poly Prep-NYC, sr.

First-team defense
E - Fred Campbell, New Rochelle-1, sr.
E - Arthur Jones, Union-Endicott-4, sr.
L - Doug Worthington, St. Francis-CHSFL-6, sr.
L - Jason Diehl, Troy-2, sr.
L - Dario Arezzo, Syracuse CBA-3, sr.
L - Jason Weber, Orchard Park-6, sr.
LB - Mike Stenclik, Webster Schroeder-5, sr.
LB - Scooter Berry, North Babylon-11, sr.
HB - Paul Anderson, Poly Prep-NYC, sr.
HB - James Starks, Niagara Falls-6, sr.
S - Glenroy Lee, New Rochelle-1, sr.
K - Tom Manning, Rome Free Academy-3, sr.

Second-team offense
E - Jeff Stehle, Central Square-3, sr.
E - Tim Bush, Saratoga-2, sr.
L - Chris Smith, St. Francis-CHSFL-6, sr.
L - Brian Mittelstadt, Carmel-1, sr.
L - Tim Bolden, North Babylon-11, sr.
L - Chris Murphy, Orchard Park-6, sr.
QB - Geoff McDermott, New Rochelle-1, sr.
RB - Ernest Jackson, Gates Chili-5, sr.
RB - Ahmad Burks, Baldwinsville-3, jr.
RB - Brian Bojko, Syracuse CBA-3, sr.
QB - Joe Zaccardo, Webster Thomas-5, sr.

Second-team defense
E - Robert Sice, Monsignor Farrell-NYC, sr.
E - Mckenzie Mathews, Syracuse CBA-3, jr.
L - Kevin Richards, Shenendehowa-2, sr.
L - Pete Taddeo, Longwood-11, sr.
L - Guillermo Ruffolo, Webster Thomas-5, sr.
LB - Joe Catalano, Albany CBA-2, sr.
LB - Richard Kissi, New Rochelle-1, sr.
LB - Matt Scalise, North Tonawanda-6, sr.
HB - Doug Fulmer, Syracuse Henninger-3, sr.
HB - James Mallory, Kenmore West-6, sr.
S / K - Brian Nelson, Shenendehowa-2, sr.

Third-team offense
E / K - Erik Estabrook, Syracuse CBA-3, sr.
L - Pete Scalia, Monroe-Woodbury-9, sr.
L - Alex Port, North Tomawanda-6, sr.
L - Colin Berry, Shaker-2, sr.
L - Jeff Schaefer, Massapequa-8, sr.
QB - Matt Stack, Monroe-Woodbury-9, sr.
RB - Lamont Downing, Sheepshead Bay-NYC, sr.
RB - Ike Nduka, White Plains-1, sr.
RB - Anthony Rios, Rochester East-5, sr.
RB - Isaac Williams, Shenendehowa-2, sr.
RB - Andy Pace, Orchard Park-6, sr.

Third-team defense
E - Jeremy Goldman, Tottenville-NYC, sr.
L - David Sanders, Liverpool-3, sr.
L - Brandon McDowell, Rochester East-5, sr.
L - Marvin Spivey, Binghamton-4, sr.
L - Gary Roker, Baldwin-8, sr.
LB - Greg Hadley, Syracuse CBA-3, jr.
LB - Matt DeLuca, East Meadow-8, sr.
LB - Carl Festa, Auburn-3, sr.
HB - Durrell Abney, Mount Vernon-1, sr.
HB - Naaman Roosevelt, Buffalo St. Joe-CHSFL-6, jr.
S - Alton Lucas, West Babylon-11, sr.

Fourth-team offense
E - Stephen Schmicke, Bellport-11, jr.
L - Dan Reedy, St. Francis-CHSFL-6, sr.
L - Rich Schofield, North Rockland-1, sr.
L - Brian McKinney, Shenendehowa-2, sr.
L - Nino Stenta, Binghamton-4, sr.
L - Rich Cummings, Syracuse CBA-3, sr.
QB - Kevin Hennessy, West Babylon-11, sr.
RB - Jihad Morris, Newburgh Free-9, jr.
RB - Rahoo Walker, Hempstead-8, sr.
RB - Kevin Collier, Churchville-Chili-5, jr.
RB - Brett Wilson, Longwood-11, sr.

Fourth-team defense
E - Robert Brown, Rome Free Academy-3, sr.
E - Nick Parker, Northport-11, sr.
L - Deni Ofodin, Union-Endicott-4, jr.
L - Jason McGee, Bellport-11, sr.
L - David Postwaite, Gates Chili-5, sr.
LB - Frank Scappaticci, St. Anthony-CHSFL, sr.
LB - Joe Russo, Utica Proctor-3, sr.
LB - Anthony Cucit, Greece Athena-5, sr.
HB - Andrew Miller, William Floyd-11, sr.
HB - Leslie Jackman, Freeport-8
S - Clarence Megwa, Binghamton-4, sr.