First team-offense
E - Pat Simonds, Sidney-4, sr.
E - Jason Poore, Hooskick Falls-2
L - Anthony Goodwin, Dobbs Ferry-1, sr.
L - Jordan Tuttel, Sidney-4, sr.
L - Alex Toth, Bronxville-1, sr.
L - Eric Manning, Hoosick Falls-2, sr.
QB - Jon Williams, Silver Creek-6, sr.
RB - Aaron Zurn, Sidney-4, sr.
RB - Mike Farabella, LeRoy-5, sr.
RB - Tony Jackson, Bishop Kearney-5, jr.
RB - Mike Dearwester, Rye Neck-1, sr.

First-team defense
E - Ben Call, General Brown-3, sr.
E - Oliver Dobbs, Dobbs Ferry-1, sr.
L - Blake Eaton, Allegany-Limestone-6, jr.
L - Jeff Daye, Delhi-4, jr.
LB - Bob Stutz, Dobbs Ferry-1, sr.
LB - Jason Bonasaro, Silver Creek-6, sr.
LB - Blake Thomas, Schuylerville-2, sr.
LB - Josh Wells, Marcus Whitman-5, sr.
HB - Conor Hackett, Bronxville-1, sr.
HB - Andy Schettino, Silver Creek-6, jr.
S - Nate Cauwels, Marcus Whitman-5, sr.

Second-team offense
E - Nick Duncan, Voorheesville-2, sr.
E - Mark Kalaba, Dobbs Ferry-1, sr.
L - Andrew Masten, Schuylerville-2, sr.
L - Ryan Sullivan, Delhi-4, sr.
L - Justin Johnson, General Brown-3, sr.
QB - Brian Farrington, Dobbs Ferry-1, sr.
QB - Chris Wickham, Marcus Whitman-5, sr.
RB - Pete Riley, Dobbs Ferry-1, sr.
RB - Josh Izzo, Stillwater-2, sr.
RB - Eric Sherman, Hannibal-3, jr.
RB - Jon Martin, Cassadaga Valley-6, sr.

Second-team defense
E - Brian Bernaducci, Pleasantville-1, sr.
E - Chris Swain, Hannibal-3, jr.
L - Jamie Holloman, Rye Neck-1, jr.
L - Karl Zobel, Avon-5, sr.
LB - Jimmy Erlwein, Sullivan West-9, sr.
LB - Cody Spicer, Falconer-6, sr.
LB - Vince Monks, Greenwich-2, sr.
LB - Mike Burpoe, Sidney-4, jr.
HB - Craig Tiberio, LeRoy-5, jr.
HB - Aaron Hallett, Caledonia-Mumford-5, sr.
S - Danny Knox, Tri-Valley-9, sr.

Third-team offense
E - Dustin Cook, Hannibal-3, sr.
E - Chris Maley, Ilion-3, sr.
L - Larry McDonald, Pine Plains-9, sr.
L - Jeff Duxbury, Greenwich-2, sr.
QB - Kyle Morenus, Sidney-4, sr.
QB - Kurt Spear, Greene-4, sr.
RB - Zac Kozersky, Schuylerville-2, sr.
RB - Brenton Hood, Delhi-4, jr.
RB - Jason Sgarlata, Canastota-3, sr.
RB - Robert Kelly, Cleveland Hill-6, sr.
RB - Bryan Wiley, Thousand Islands-3, sr.

Third-team defense
L - Jeff Beaver, Buffalo Burgard-6, jr.
L - Doug Herman, Watervliet-2, sr.
L - Joe Whisher, Ausable Valley-7, jr.
LB - Jared Kimmel, Harpursville-4, sr.
LB - Pat Combo, Caledonia-Mumford-5, sr.
LB - Alex McLean, Sidney-4, sr.
LB - Louis Buck, Lake George-2, sr.
DB - Zach Whittaker, Greene-4, sr.
DB - Adam Barrett, Avon-5, sr.
DB - Damien Crance, Cheektowaga JFK-6, sr.
S - Pat Schweiger, Elmira Edison-4, sr.