First-team offense
E - Mike O'Rourke, sr., Cornwall-9
E - Preston Soeprasetyo, sr., Carmel-1
L - Nick Christman, sr., Sweet Home-6
L - Rick Antinelli, sr., Aquinas-5
L - James Thomas, sr., Aquinas-5
L - Derek Sable, sr., Harrison-1
QB - Dave Boisture, sr., Cornwall-9
RB - Calvin McCoy, sr., Fordham Prep-CHSFL
RB - Rashaad Slowley, sr., White Plains Stepinac-CHSFL
RB - Robert Grimm. Sr., Carthage-3
RB - Kenny Youngs, sr., Lansingburgh-2

First-team defense
E - Matt Jones, sr., Aquinas-5
E - Jajuan Perez, sr., Ossining-1
L - Keith Goodluck, sr., Lawrence-8
L - Randy Colling, sr., Pioneer-6
L - Quinin Jones, sr., Rochester Marshall-5
LB - Bill O'Connor, sr., Sayville-11
LB - Chris Sawyer, sr., Lansingburgh-2
LB - Tommy Lewis, sr., Iroquois-6
LB - Devin Worthington, jr., Aquinas-5
HB - Vinnie Nicosia, sr., Amsterdam-2
HB - Todd Wingate, sr., Aquinas-5

Second-team offense
E - Mike Kelly, sr., New Hartford-3
E - Paul Evans, sr., Iroquois-6
L - David Skrip, sr., Albion-6
L - Bilal Butt, sr. Sewanhaka-8
L - Jake Havernick, sr., Cheektowaga-6
QB - Mike Mathews, sr., Fox Lane-1
QB - P.J. Preziosa, sr., Lawrence-8
RB - Anthony Fitts, sr., Aquinas-5
RB - Arvin Bell, sr., Buffalo McKinley-6
RB - Justin Fredericks, sr., Lawrence-8
RB - Wayne Washington, sr., East Irondequoit Eastridge-5

Second-team defense
L - Rob Lombardo, jr., Somers-1
L - Alex Palkovic, sr., Burnt Hills-2
L - Pat Landry, sr., Carthage-3
L - Homer Dobransky, jr., Carthage-3
L - Josh Jesonoswki, sr., Iroquois
LB - Tyler Brown, sr., Indian River-10
LB - Anton Rukaj, sr., White Plains Stepinac-CHSFL
LB - Edgar Cesar, sr., Islip-11
HB - Kevin Arduino, jr., Cornwall-9
HB - Marcus Johnson, sr., Sweet Home-6
K - Joe Flint, sr., Amsterdam-2

Third-team offense
E - Dorian Dorsey, sr., Fox Lane-1
E - Pete Lamacchia, sr., Fordham Prep-CHSFL
L - Connan Ingham, sr., Fulton-3
L - Jeremy Jordan, sr., Burnt Hills-2
L - Craig Kutzin, sr., Eastchester-1
L - Phil Hayden, sr., Mexico-3
QB - Paul Layton, jr., Burnt Hills-2
QB - Joshua Straits, sr., Indian River-10
RB - Matt Cushing, sr., East Syracuse-Minoa-3
RB - Nyquan McGirt, sr., Lansingburgh-2
RB - James Brundage, jr., Ossining-1

Third-team defense
E - Adee Dubray, sr., Ossining-1
L - Will Parker, sr., Corning East-4
L - Corey Gerace, sr., East Syracuse-Minoa-3
LB - Kevin Glueckert, sr., Bethpage-8
LB - Steve Means, sr., Glover Cleveland-6
LB - Ryan Hunt, jr., White Plains Stepinac-CHSFL
LB - Maurice Gibbs, sr., Buffalo McKinley-6
HB - Bundka Kargbo, jr., Bishop Maginn-2
HB - Jon Roberts, sr., Elmira Free Academy-4
HB - Travis Kennedy, sr., Lawrence-8
S - Maurice Easterling, soph., White Plains Stepinac-CHSFL