First-team offense
E - James Bonsall, sr., Rye-1
E - Jeff Watson, sr., Marcellus-3
L - Kevin Dudkowski, sr., Depew-6
L - G.O. Ozkhan, sr., Bishop Ford-CHSFL
L - Sam Fulmer, sr., Rye-1
QB - Jordan Eck, sr., Rye-1
RB - Dale Ross, sr. Syracuse Westhill-3
RB - Jeremiah Allen, sr., Geneva-5
RB - Davia Zapata, sr., Hornell-5
RB - Lewis Dendy, sr., Bishop Ford-CHSFL
K - Sebastian Saunders, sr., Rye-1

First-team defense
L - Jud Dubois, sr., Chenango Forks-4
L - Art Garvey, sr., East Aurora-6
L - Matt Bobal, sr., Chenango Valley-4
L - Joe Webb, sr., Lackawanna-6
LB - Jake Reynolds, sr., Chenango Forks-4
LB - Steven Amaro, sr., Sleepy Hollow-1
LB - Art Bigsby, sr., Cazenovia-3
LB - Bill Smith, sr., Nanuet-1
HB - Mike Sapriacone, sr., Seaford-8
HB - Jamel Lyde, sr., Sleepy Hollow-1
HB - Garret Cade, sr., Chenango Forks-4

Second-team offense
E - Jimmer Bennett, jr., Albany Academy-2
E - Shane Biggs, sr., East Aurora-6
L - Ken Meyer, sr., Cardinal Spellman-CHSFL
L - Mike Raplee, jr., Geneva-5
L - Jake Asquino, sr., Seaford-8
L - Matt Bonomolo, jr., Nanuet-1
QB - Cole Koesterer, sr., Cazenovia-3
QB - Tyler Hoey, sr., Peru-7
RB - Joe Aston, sr., Chenango Forks-4
RB - Seamus Kelly, jr., Xavier-CHSFL
RB - Kyle Ramaljo, jr., Rye-1

Second-team defense
L - Mike Carboine, sr., Homer-3
L - Eli Remillard, sr., Peru-7
L - Alex Dumas, sr., New Paltz-9
L - Clint Cade, sr., Chenango Forks-4
LB - Steve Ferrazzara, sr., Burke Catholic-9
LB - Ben Carl, sr., Solvay-3
LB - Brian Paeglow, sr., Ravena-2
LB - Jimmy Warner, sr., Geneva-5
HB - Greg Osika, sr., Depew-6
HB - Dave Mandelbaum, sr., Edgemont-1
HB - Robert McIntosh, sr., Cardinal Spellman-CHSFL

Third-team offense
E - Alec Currier, sr., Peru-7
L - Aaron Walker, sr., Rye-1
L - Kevin Duffy, sr., Cobleskill-2
L - Jon King, sr., Jamestown Southwestern-6
L - Jon Bayerl, jr., Depew-6
E - Kevin Hanson, jr., Fonda-Fultonville-2
QB - Neal Dotterer, jr., East Rochester-5
QB - Josh Keller, sr., Cobleskill-2
RB - Brandy Raynor, sr., Fredonia-6
RB - Mike Hayes, sr., Broadalbin-Perth-2
RB - Chris Nourse, sr., Cazenovia-3

Third-team defense
L - Alex Golda, sr., Lackawanna-6
L - Chad Brust, sr., Cobleskill-2
L - Trevor Tompkins, sr., Liberty-9
L - Tom Trendowski, sr., Syracuse Westhill-3
L - Marcus Schokker, sr., Cazenovia-3
LB - Jared Thurber, sr., Bradalbin-Perth-2
LB - Anthony Van Curen, sr., Burke Catholic-9
LB - Aaron Christman, sr., Cobleskill-2
HB - Matt Strachyski, sr., Depew-6
HB - Kevin Gordon, sr., Rye-1
K - Andrew Bartholomew, sr., Cobleskill-2